情境完整性下闭环神经反馈技术的伦理审视Ethical Examination of Closed-Loop Neurofeedback Through the Lens of Contextual Integrity
居昊祺
摘要(Abstract):
随着闭环神经反馈技术的研发与应用不断推进,有必要立足脑机接口的临床与非临床两类情境,开展系统的伦理审视。本文以情境完整性为分析框架,从情境、角色、信息属性与传输原则四个维度考察闭环神经反馈的信息流转及其规范后果。不同于将伦理问题简化为隐私泄露、数据滥用或一般风险管控的进路,本文进一步引入伦理学理论资源,指出闭环系统的长期运行可能重组用户与医生、学校、雇主及技术平台之间的依赖关系,改变个体理解自身、解释自身和退出技术实践的能力。在临床情境中,治理重点在于通过参数改动审核、数据分级、关键日志与再同意触发机制维护患者福祉和脆弱自主;在非临床情境中,治理重点在于通过“非用户不受罚”、分数去考核化、用途限定与跨场景“防火墙”,防止标签化、隐性强制与功能漂移。以情境完整性为判准,闭环神经反馈治理应从标准建构转向伦理回应,将自主、尊严、公平和可纠偏性落实为可执行、可审计的制度安排。
关键词(KeyWords): 闭环神经反馈技术;情境完整性;技术伦理;伦理治理;伦理审视
基金项目(Foundation): 国家社会科学基金重点项目“脑机接口技术创新的哲学基础与伦理困境研究”(25AZX022)
作者(Author): 居昊祺
DOI: 10.16112/j.cnki.53-1160/c.2026.05.124
参考文献(References):
- [1]Sitaram R,Ros T,Stoeckel L,et al.Closed-loop brain training:the science of neurofeedback[J].Nature Reviews Neuroscience,2017,18(2).
- [2]Slutzky M W,Vansteensel M J,Herff C,et al.A brain-computer interface working definition[J].Nature Biomedical Engineering,2025,9(6):792.
- [3]Shibata K,Watanabe T,Sasaki Y,et al.Perceptual learning incepted by decoded fMRI neurofeedback without stimulus presentation[J].Science,2011,334(6061):1413-1415.
- [4]Haag L,Starke G,Ploner M,et al.Ethical gaps in closed-loop neurotechnology:a scoping review[J].npj Digital Medicine,2025,8:510.
- [5]Kellmeyer P,Cochrane T,Müller O,et al.The effects of closed-loop medical devices on the autonomy and accountability of persons and systems[J].Cambridge Quarterly of Healthcare Ethics,2016,25(4).
- [6]Muňoz K A,Kostick K,Sanchez C,et al.Researcher perspectives on ethical considerations in adaptive deep brain stimulation trials[J].Frontiers in Human Neuroscience,2020,14:578695.
- [7]Steinert S,Friedrich O.Wired emotions:ethical issues of affective brain-computer interfaces[J].Science and Engineering Ethics,2020,26(1):351-367.
- [8]Nagappan A,Kalokairinou L,Wexler A.Ethical and legal considerations of alternative neurotherapies[J].AJOB Neuroscience,2021,12(4):257-269.
- [9]梁晓珊,白彩珍,杨艺,等.脑机接口伦理审查的国际视野与中国实践[J].医学与哲学,2025,46(22).
- [10]杜青.非侵入式脑机接口在儿童神经发育障碍康复中的应用与展望[J].中国康复医学杂志,2026,41(3):337-341.
- [11]何金洋,梅杰,黄文锲,等.强化学习优化脑机接口系统理论及其应用综述[J].模式识别与人工智能,2026,39(6):537-553.
- [12]Guetschel P,Ahmadi S,Tangermann M.Review of deep representation learning techniques for brain-computer interfaces[J].Journal of Neural Engineering,2024,21(6):061002.
- [13]平安,朱君明.神经调控治疗药物难治性癫痫:从开环到闭环刺激[J].中国现代神经疾病杂志,2026,26(1):50-56.
- [14]Zrenner C,Ziemann U.Closed-loop brain stimulation[J].Biological Psychiatry,2024,95(6):545-552.
- [15]Nissenbaum H.Privacy in context:technology,policy,and the integrity of social life[M].Stanford:Stanford University Press,2010.
- [16]Cortese A,Amano K,Koizumi A,et al.Multivoxel neurofeedback selectively modulates confidence without changing perceptual performance[J].Nature Communications,2016,7:13669.
- [17]Nissenbaum H.Privacy as contextual integrity[J].Washington Law Review,2004,79(1):119-157.
- [18]Ros T,Enriquez-Geppert S,Zotev V,et al.Consensus on the reporting and experimental design of clinical and cognitive-behavioural neurofeedback studies (CRED-nf checklist)[J].Brain,2020,143(6):1674-1685.